What If?

FAQ

FAQ

FAQ

What is alternate history?

Alternate history is a genre of speculation that explores “what if” scenarios, imagining how history might have unfolded differently. On this site, members discuss hypothetical changes to historical events, from minor shifts to major reimaginings, and explore their possible effects on the world.

How can I start a new discussion?

To start a new discussion, head to the the “Submit a Post or Poll” button on the main forum page. From there, write a title and add your content. Please check that a similar topic hasn’t already been posted. Including historical context and references can help others engage with your idea!

Are there any guidelines for creating posts?

Yes! We encourage posts that are respectful, historically informed, and speculative in nature. Avoid making modern political or sensitive topics a primary focus unless the scenario relates directly to historical events. Always respect others’ viewpoints and support your ideas with historical context.

What kinds of alternate history topics are allowed?

We welcome all sorts of alternate history topics, from ancient to modern times. Whether you’re interested in imagining what would have happened if Rome never fell or how the world might look if the Cold War had gone hot, you’re welcome here. However, discussions should stay rooted in plausible or speculative history.

Can I include images, maps, or other media in my posts?

Absolutely! Visual aids like maps, timelines, and images can enhance your scenario. Just ensure that any media you share is either in the public domain or that you have permission to use it. This helps keep our community respectful of copyright laws.

How do I make my posts more engaging?

Provide historical context, include hypothetical outcomes, and ask thought-provoking questions to invite others to contribute. Adding references, such as historical events, figures, or timelines, can also help others understand and engage with your alternate scenario.

Do I need historical expertise to participate?

Not at all! Our community is for anyone with an interest in history, from curious beginners to seasoned experts. We encourage you to share your ideas, learn from others, and explore how history might have unfolded differently. Passion and curiosity are all you need to join in.